4. Organising huge amounts of data
One of the big promises of AI, and especially deep learning, is the ability to integrate data from different sources into a coherent set.
‘AI will bring great value,’ Silvia comments, ‘when it comes to integrating what can be defined as different modalities. It’s very hard for an individual clinical trial manager to put together information about patients that combines data from different medical fields – from imagery to ‘omics’ (e.g. genomics, metabolomics and proteomics). Yet we need to take all of these into account and draw value out of this big blob of heterogeneous information.
Anyone who has used ChatGPT has witnessed generative AI’s ability to sift through information and organise it clearly at record speed. Having this information at their fingertips will mean doctors can make decisions faster for their patients.
5. Helping doctors do their jobs better
AI-assisted doctors have been a hot topic over the last few years, as they reveal a shift in the way healthcare is delivered to patients.
Nora gives examples of tools already available: ‘LLMs can dig through the clinical records of patients and summarise data for the care team. They can also help doctors by drafting replies to patients’ questions. There are tools that help doctors recommend treatments based on the literature, and others that take notes and queue suggested orders for clinician sign-off. When used with proper human oversight, these tools save time without replacing clinical judgement.’
This has prompted some to wonder about whether we’ll see a drop in quality as these tools are deployed. Will there be a shift away from expert human judgement towards generic, mediocre machine-generated answers?
However, Silvia explains the opposite is happening: ‘Surveys have been carried out with junior doctors to understand what value LLMs are bringing. They were asked whether they see LLMs as oracles, second opinions or something in between. The majority rated the level of expertise of these LLMs as very senior. So they can certainly act as a decision support tool and give confidence, especially to junior doctors who don’t have much experience.’
That said, Silvia also warns of the need to tread carefully in this area. ‘Ultimately, the human relationship with a patient is so important, and it’s impossible to recreate this with AI tools.’
The most successful AI tools don’t replace the clinician. Rather, they support them, make their lives easier and help them sort through vast amounts of data. In his book Deep Medicine: How Artificial Intelligence Can Make Healthcare Human Again, Eric Topol goes one step further. He argues that AI will not lessen human contact, but quite the opposite: ‘The greatest opportunity offered by AI is not reducing errors or workloads, or even curing cancer: it is the opportunity to restore the precious and time-honored connection and trust.’ By speeding up admin tasks, doctors will have longer to fully focus on their patients.
Still, it’s important not to rely excessively on these technologies. ‘Doctors will need to be very careful,’ warns Silvia, ‘not to forsake their own instincts and blindly follow instructions from AI tools. This is especially true for more unusual cases. Machine learning tools are better at generalising based on something that happens frequently than at understanding the exception. They’re very weak at adapting to new situations that aren’t represented in the data they have been trained on. These tools are generalists, not specialists.’
Developing AI solutions together
Although both Silvia and Nora are advocates for AI tools in the life sciences, they are also aware of the challenges and risks that lie ahead. There are difficulties to tackle related to infrastructure and staffing, as Christopher Rudolf mentions in his interview with us this month.
But perhaps the biggest obstacle is that mindsets will need to change. Silvia remarks: ‘In some of our partnerships, it’s taken a long time for stakeholders to adopt an AI tool and use it on patients. 90% of the way to adoption is not about innovative potential, but a shift in mindsets. We need to develop tools in close collaboration with medical staff so that they trust these solutions.
So, to reap the full benefits of AI tools in the life sciences, they shouldn’t be developed in a silo. Close collaboration between tech companies and medical staff is the way to produce truly useful tools that are trusted, and bring value, to doctors and patients alike.